Is Lyon's portrait of Aristotle accurate Does it match what Classics Research Paper

Is Lyons portrait of Aristotle accurate Does it match what Classics scholars know about Aristotle - Research Paper ExampleLyons Aristotle and black lovage are passing credible portrayals of a great thinker confined by the exacting discipline learned under Plato, and of the strong-willed and heedless young son of Phillip of Macedon. Lyon writes a telling exchange between the two that encapsulates the complex self-propelled at work in one of historys most engrossing relationships. Lyon addresses the constitutional difference between them. You conflate pleasure and happiness, real enduring happiness, Aristotle remonstrates. A few thrills, a few sensations. Your basic woman, your first elephant, your first spicy meal, your first hangover, your first ascent of a mountain no mans ever climbed, and your first view from the top to the other side. You want to string together a life of thrills. Name 2 With characteristic self-assuredness, black lovage responds, Teach me better then. Com e with my army. Come with me. Youve been a father to me. Dont divest me twice (Lyon, 278). Its an affecting scene one might expect to take place between an older, wiser father and an impetuous son. It is unlikely that the headstrong Alexander would have yielded to his tutor, despite the great scholars renown, anywhere but in the classroom. ... History affords few such comparative character studies, few that award such a fascinating contrast of personalities involved both emotionally and in conflict. Here is a rare intellectual collision the wintry hearted philosopher and the afterlife military commander, whose own incipient depression is ca utilize not by a lack of passion, but a surfeit (MacDonald, 2009). Both men are dynamic in their own ways, but Alexander ultimately outstrips his brilliant but repressed tutor. It is Alexander who ultimately wins the book-long joust with his tutor, since he is a man who not only feels but also acts (MacDonald, 2009). Aristotle and Alexander ap pear to have comprised something of an odd couple Alexander the A-type personality, non-reflective and dynamic while Aristotle, who had seen military service, by comparison a bookish, non-physical, even effeminate type, according to Name 3 ancient accounts. The biographer Diogenes Laertius, drawing on secondary and tertiary accounts, wrote that He had a lisping voice, as is asserted by Timotheus the AthenianHe had also very thin legs, they say, and small eyes but he used to indulge in very conspicuous dress, and rings, and used to dress his hair carefully (Shields, 419-20). Lyon tells us that Alexanders view of Aristotles golden mean was, at best, derisive, telling Aristotle that his middle way philosophical system prizes mediocrity (Lyon, 193). In spite of such criticism, Lyons treatment of the complex relationship between Aristotle and Alexander serves as a kind of cautionary tale. Alexander fails to learn important lessons that are really about character and